Could Trump and the Tijuana Mayor Make a Caravan Deal?

By Monica Showalter, 11-24-18, at American Thinker:

After failing to guard its southern borders from Central America’s migrant caravan as it busted through and then providing buses and succor as it snaked northward, Mexico has effectively dumped the entire caravan mess onto its northern city of Tijuana, leaving it with the cost of caring for the uninvited migrants whose prospects for entering the U.S. legally are dim.

Such nice people. But it’s about par for Mexico City, given the famous contempt with which Mexico’s elites hold the country’s northernmost industrial metropolis. Americans can easily sympathize with the plight of Tijuana, given Mexico City’s behavior.

According to the mayor of Tijuana, Mexico City has actually abandoned them, sending no extra money to help cover the costs of its winked-and-nodded-at caravan. More migrants are arriving by the day, crime is up, and now disease is spreading. Now he’s calling for international help.

According to the Daily Mail:

The mayor of Tijuana has declared a humanitarian crisis in his border city and is asking the United Nations for aid to deal with 5,000 Central American migrants who arrived there.

The comments by Mayor Juan Manuel Gastelum came as city officials and volunteers worked together to assist the 4,976 men, women and children who traveled there and are sleeping outside and inside a sports complex.

What’s more, Tijuana officials and citizens are placing the blame exactly where it belongs:

Manuel Figueroa, who leads the city’s social services department, said Tijuana was bringing in portable toilets and showers, as well as shampoo and soap.

‘Because of the absence, the apathy and the abandonment of the federal government, we are having to turn to international institutions like the UN’, Figueroa said.

Rene Vazquez, 60, a Tijuana resident who was volunteering at the stadium, said Mexico’s federal government ignored the problem by allowing the caravan to cross the country without stopping. Now the city of 1.6 million is stuck with the fallout.

With that the consensus, it may be a golden opportunity for President Trump to step in and give Tijuana the resources it needs. Sure, diplomacy is done state-to-state, not state-to-municipality. But recent decades have loosened that up a bit, and Trump is nothing if not unconventional. Tijuana has a tradition of acting unconventionally, too. Meanwhile, Trump is one of the players in a position of strength, with Mexico City showing weakness and Tijuana feeling the squeeze. So any arrangement would not come for free, of course, but as part of extending Trump’s leverage through a deal.

Because the political aspect of the picture seems to present opportunities. In TJ, the general sentiment is that Mexico City is withholding aid because Tijuana’s mayor is a conservative and not part of the current ruling party. According to RT News:

[Tijuana Mayor Juan Manuel] Gastelum, who is in opposition to the current Mexican government, has been vocal in his disdain for the federal authorities and has sided with US President Donald Trump. Gastelum stirred controversy after he was spotted wearing a red “Make Tujuana great again” cap, and invited an endorsement by the US President himself, who tweeted that like Tijuana, the US is “ill-prepared for this invasion.”

Friendly Tweets from Trump and signs of friendliness from the mayor of Tijuana, who after all, knows his city’s economy is closely linked to a gate with the U.S. and both are conservatives…

I’ll throw out a proposal and though I know not everyone will like it, it just seems like something that could happen to a good result, given President Trump’s experience and success with direct negotiations, and the desirability of keeping the UN’s corrupt pontificators out of the region.

The U.S. helps Tijuana with its humanitarian needs surrounding the migrant caravan as its denizens await their asylum appointments. Any aid, very basic, should also be open to the poor of Tijuana as well.

Tijuana does all it can to discourage future migrant caravans from making their way to the border, from added razor wire of its own on the Mexico side to added city security to prevent a border rush.  (Some of this has apparently already been done but there could be more.)

Tijuana holds the caravan organizers who foisted this humanitarian crisis onto the city, Pueblo Sin Fronteras, accountable – and if the latter can’t pay for the food and upkeep of the migrants they enticed to the border in this humanitarian crisis, well, then they’ll have to go to jail for humanitarian crimes.

Tijuana encourages the migrants to accept jobs at Tijuana’s labor-starved maquiladoras (manufacturing factories)- or else no aid.

And some of the aid can be for bus trips for the migrants back to their homelands where they will be encouraged to apply to the U.S. legally.

It’s just a starting ballpark, but the fun of it is that such a deal would drive Mexico City (and U.S. Democrats) crazy. Trump is famous for unconventional dealings, and in an unconventional political challenge such as the invading caravan, a deal could do a lot of good, not just to restore regular legal migration, but to end the perception that Trump is anti-Latino when in fact he and his supporters are just pro-rule of law. Tijuana could benefit from the whole thing, too, and get its problem gone.

Here’s to hoping something like this could be tried.


What an interesting concept that just might work.  In the long run, it would be much cheaper for the US to help Mayor Gastelum keep them there in Tijuana than it would be to let them in. It could also prevent a stampede on the border and leave them no choice but to either return home or find a job and a place to live.

I have no idea how you would target a municipality with aid, but if anyone can figure it out, I’d bet Trump can.


Categories: Political

Tags: , ,

6 replies

  1. I like Monica Showalter. She’s a smart cookie. If anyone might succeed at this, it would be Trump. The people in Tijuana like Trump and blame this mess on their own government in video after video.

    The border has just been closed there due to 500 migrants rushing the border, throwing stones and leading with women and children. They pushed through fencing but were met with non lethal weapons.

    Pray for our border police and our troops. They are in danger there and we all are too.


    • Tijuana is considered conservative, so naturally the problem gets dumped on them and they get ignored by their liberal government. Those migrants will likely leave there and go to other places to cross that aren’t as well guarded. Meanwhile, because of their pushing and shoving, other people can’t get to and from work if that crossing stays closed.

      It is imperative we stand firm on this right now.


  2. I’m struggling with this one because of this notion these migrants have that they can simply force themselves on other countries with the expectation of being sheltered and cared for at others’ expense even when they are not fleeing from war or persecution. That said, unless we can permanently secure the border our options are somewhat limited right now, and while ideally we need to restore the world’s respect for law and order and national sovereignty, the priority in this moment must be to prevent people from entering the U.S. illegally. So I am reluctantly on board.


    • Considering who (namely liberals) gave the migrants the notion they could barge in are the same people as the ones who want to do away with ICE. They’re the same ones who preach to us about having compassion, so it’s not surprising they expected to be welcomed in.

      This possible solution of keeping them in Mexico isn’t perfect, no plan is, but at this point I’d support just about anything to keep them out. I’m really sick & tired of being the bad guys because we want to uphold our laws.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. He might be able to provide focused aid through the Trump Foundation. That would not only get the aid there, but it would control it like the NGOs do not.

    Maybe a tent city, with showers, toilets and mess hall somewhere SOUTH of TJ. Maybe off Highway 1D and Segundo Accesso near Corona Dal Mar.


    • That might be a conflict of interest that would get him in more hot water, unless it was done behind the scenes so nobody knows he did it. I don’t see Trump operating secretly like that – he wants people to know all the good he’s doing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: